An Objectivist Critique of “Self-Ownership”


Paul McKeever does us a great service in the following video, where he argues that there can be no such thing as self-ownership unless you believe in a soul. Obviously Mr. McKeever thinks this disproves the concept of self-ownership because a soul is an imaginary religious thing that has no business in philosophy.

Read »
michaelsuede's picture
Created by michaelsuede 1 year 37 weeks ago
Category:   Tags:

Wow, what a terrible argument

phonon 1 year 37 weeks 6 hours 2 min ago

There's no self-ownership because the mind isn't separate from the body and if the mind owns the body then it's like the liver owning the body. I guess someone owning a toothbrush is the same as saying that his liver owns a toothbrush, which is obviously absurd. Therefore, no one can own a toothbrush. No one can own anything. There is no such thing as ownership or property. Congratulations, comrade.

It's not necessary to separate the mind and body to claim self ownership. All that's necessary is the claim itself. If you have consciousness, can claim ownership, and others recognize that claim of ownership, then you have a condition of ownership. That applies to yourself or any of your possessions. It's no more complicated than that.

Not really

michaelsuede 1 year 37 weeks 5 hours 40 min ago

In the statement "I own myself", the I and myself are two distinct individuals. To highlight this, consider the statement, "I can't live with myself" - who is I and who is myself? "I" refers to conscious awareness, "myself" refers to the ego or mind. "I" is the silent observer, where the mind (myself) is the ego or mental noise that is creating mental conflict. To claim ownership of one's self, is to claim the observer is the owner of the ego.

Only if you're schizophrenic or something

phonon 1 year 36 weeks 6 days 1 hour ago

"I" and "myself" are the same person, but the words are different because of this thing called grammar. You're making something way more complicated than it needs to be.

Air Times & Contact

LIVE 7 Days a Week!
Mon-Sun: 7pm-10pm Eastern

Call toll-free:

You can also Skype us.

Join our Email List

Stay up to date with the latest about Free Talk Live, and receive our Weekly Digest email - the most popular stories for the week from our front page and also the week's audio highlights!

See our past emails.

Free Talk Live 2.5

Welcome Free Talk Live 2.5! Now, with Reddit!
You'll need a Reddit account before you can vote on and submit show prep. (That is different from your FTL/AMP account.)

The content here is the same as you will see on the FTL Subreddit. Please submit bug reports on the appropriate BBS subforum.

Enjoy the new site and thanks for submitting your content!


New forum topics

Recent Posts Recent Posts

Who's online

There are currently 2 users and 1 guest online.

Online users

  • davidfordhere
  • Temper