Ethicists Argue Killing Newborn Babies Should Be Allowed

The authors argue that “both fetuses and newborns do not have the same moral status as actual persons,” and that because abortion is allowed even when there is no problem with the fetus’ health, “killing a newborn should be permissible in all the cases where abortion is, including cases where the newborn is not disabled.”

I actually agree with the science behind the premise.

CaptainWhomp 3 years 25 weeks 6 days 22 hours ago

No, I don't think we should make aborting newborns legal. However, two things which make people individuals are 1) self-awareness of their own existence, and 2) the ability to disapprove of pain beyond a simple stimulus/response mechanism which can be demonstrated by even the most basic of all lifeforms (e.g. amoebas). Cognitive scientists and biologists put this level of mental development at two years after birth, not at any time during the pregnancy. So technically, abortions could rationally extend up until 2 years old.

However, I'm pretty sure the entire world would scream about such a proposition, for whatever non-scientific biases and objections they may have. Plus, it is very likely unnecessary to extend abortion beyond birth, for the obvious reason that if you haven't decided by then, what on Earth has taken so long? So let's just round the deadline back down to birth and keep it there, where it is now.

Air Times & Contact

LIVE 7 Days a Week!
Mon-Sun: 7pm-10pm Eastern

Call toll-free:

You can also Skype us.

Join our Email List

Stay up to date with the latest about Free Talk Live, and receive our Weekly Digest email - the most popular stories for the week from our front page and also the week's audio highlights!

See our past emails.

Free Talk Live 2.5

Welcome Free Talk Live 2.5! Now, with Reddit!
You'll need a Reddit account before you can vote on and submit show prep. (That is different from your FTL/AMP account.)

The content here is the same as you will see on the FTL Subreddit. Please submit bug reports on the appropriate BBS subforum.

Enjoy the new site and thanks for submitting your content!


New forum topics

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 0 guests online.
Free Talk Live Image
Free Talk Live Image
Free Talk Live Image
Free Talk Live Image
Liberty Stickers
Watch the Ridley Report
Mark Warden - New Hampshire Realtor
Free Talk Live Image
Free Talk Live Image
Free Talk Live Image
Free Talk Live Image
shiny badges
Midas Resources
Advertise Market Promote with AMP
Free Keene - NH Liberty Activism
Free State Project
Join the Shire Society
Free Talk Live Image
Freedom's Phoenix
stitcher smartradio
FTL on AudioNow